« links for 2006-03-02 | Main | links for 2006-03-04 »

March 02, 2006

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c609853ef00d834319ee253ef

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Global Online Freedom Act: needs improvement.:

» Google's Brin on operating in China from Imagethief
Having recently suggested that it was important for the founders of US Internet companies at the heart... [Read More]

Comments

mahathir_fan

Is there not a proper civil procedure to ask for information from Yahoo? The GOFA is inviting hostility.

I agree that if US companies hand over information to Chinese authorities for the purposes of "kissing up" and "winning favors", then that should be considered bribery.

However, US companies must nevertheless comply with Chinese laws. For example, if Chinese authorities produces a court issued warrant for information, then US companies should cooperate with them. A warrant is only issued by a judge after careful consideration.

That is if Chinese authorities acted in accordance with Chinese laws, and in accordance with Chinese laws, US companies are obligated to turn over information then they should do so. Unless, US companies finds a loophole in the law - for example storing information overseas etc. etc..
then they need not comply.

The rules are already laid out clearly. If they are not, US companies should challenge them in the Chinese legal system. If US companies find that such laws are difficult to follow, they should not be in the Chinese market or they should challenge those information requests in the court of law.

hi

to mahathir_fan:
there areno laws in china,there
are only commands of ccp. if u dont obey the commands of ccp , u
break the chinese laws

mahathir_fan


Wait...why is CCP making the rules? I think it is spelt out very clearly how rules are made in China, through the NPC.

Based on my understanding, there are many sub-committees that make laws that get translated up the chain until it finally reaches NPC.

It is a similar system of drafting laws like how the telecoms industry drafts standards - for example GSM. They meet once a year to ratify the standards, at other times, they convene in special groups.

Also, it should be okay, after all China is the world's largest democracy. I see people in China voting, haven't you?

see: http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/en/doc/2003-12/08/content_288018.htm

hi

to mahathir_fan :
where r u now ,mahathir_fan?dont
let ccp fool u.ccp rules everything .there is only one party in china,the other partys r controled by ccp.there is only one religion.that s Marxism.all the candidates are nominated by ccp.chinese people will never know who they are what they look like. the candidates will never address people.
vote? it s just like to play a gambling game.

mahathir_fan

".there is only one religion.that s Marxism."

Are you saying China is like the Vatican? I have heard that in the Vatican, the people there have no choice on electing the pope. The pope is decided by some secret voting system. Also, their followers are led to believe that the pope is holy and that they will go to heaven after they die. There is also no freedom of religion in the Vatican. Everyone had to be a Catholic and there is no other religious sanctuary other than the church.

I wonder, when reporters without boundary will start picking on the Vatican instead of China? I have seen the VAtican followers come out during the last days of John Paul II. They crowded the streets all over the world and held up candles. It is very sad to see that the amount of propaganda that has been churned out to propell the people to be so devoted. It reminds me of North Korea. In North Korea, Kim Jong Il is their pope.

William

Because you do know China, a traditional feodal country, deeply sunk in its culture, political and economics, which has been completed in about 2 thousand years. Marxism is not so popular temporary there; Instead a new centralized government has been formed in the name of New society.
At the help of internet, the world synthesizes together !

Millions of Chinese

I dont think you have any necessity to leave such a bunch of nonsense. how much do you know about chinese and its culture?
Let me tell you, wherever you go, the law is that you've been told what should do and not! there is command, also the law is there. the law called the Constitutions of republic of China.

people who like talking about something they dont really know are actually ignorant.

The comments to this entry are closed.

My Photo

Global Voices


  • Global Voices Online - The world is talking. Are you listening?

  • Donate to Global Voices - Help us spread the word
Blog powered by Typepad
Member since 10/2004

license

My book:

Consent of the Networked
Coming January 31st, 2012, from Basic Books. To pre-order click here.
AddThis Feed Button